Shelter Island, NY home prices
Shelter Island, NY is rising, a premium-priced area.
Momentum+1.5%Rising
Vs typical+453%Premium
Real Estate Price Map scores, derived from the data on this page · how we calculate them
2023: $1,533,725 → today: $1,829,432 (1.2×)
Typical home value
$1,829,432
Zillow ZHVI
Since 2023
+19.3%
Rank in NY
#23
of 840 cities
Market read
At $1,829,432, homes in Shelter Island are 453% above the typical NY city ($330,584), ranking #23 of 840 we track in the state.
Prices are up 1.5% over the last year.
Shelter Island sits in Suffolk County — see the full county market data →
Home value history
Zillow Home Value Index, yearly.
Other cities in New York
Sagaponack · Water Mill · Bridgehampton · Wainscott · Sands Point · Amagansett
Frequently asked questions
What is the average home price in Shelter Island, NY?
The typical Shelter Island, NY home is worth $1,829,432 — 453% above the typical New York city ($330,584).
Are home prices in Shelter Island rising?
Shelter Island home values have risen +19.3% since 2023, and moved +1.5% in the last year.
What county is Shelter Island in?
Shelter Island is in Suffolk County, where you can see full county market data.
| Year | Shelter Island, NY home value |
|---|---|
| 2023 | $1,533,725 |
| 2024 | $1,715,525 |
| 2025 | $1,802,940 |
| 2026 | $1,829,432 |